kaminazuki shigure fururashi okuyama wa toyama no momiji ima sakarinari
In the Godless Month Chill showers have fallen, it seems, Deep within the mountains, while On the peaks nearby the scarlet leaves Are now at their finest.
shiguresuru momiji no nishiki yukashiki ni akete o tatamu futamura no yama
Under the showers The scarlet leaves’ brocade I long to see, so With the dawn let’s set forth To Mount Futamura!
Jakunen 51
Right (Win)
みやこにもおもひやすらむくさまくらうちしぐれたるよはのねざめを
miyako ni mo omoiyasuramu kusamakura uchishiguretaru yowa no nezame o
Even in the capital Might you think of me? On a grassy pillow With a shower Awoken at midnight…
Suke 52
The Left poem’s ‘With the dawn let’s set forth / To Mount Futamura’ sounds charming, but as we can see from Lord Kanesuke’s poem ‘Futami Bay / Let’s see with the dawn’, it is quite pedestrian. Then there is the expression ‘long to see’—this really isn’t appropriate diction for poetry. I will admit that it appears from time to time in imperial anthologies, and so it is certainly permissible depending upon the style of the poem, though. There’s also the term ‘long to know’—one really shouldn’t use diction in a poetry match which doesn’t express the poet’s true feelings. As for the Right’s poem, it’s also quite pedestrian to say that showers fall on one’s way on a journey, but don’t necessarily fall in the capital, but saying that folk there might think of you waking on your journey, well, why wouldn’t they do that? The conception of the poem is pleasant, and I make it the winner.
obotsukana izure urago no yama naran mina kurenai ni miyuru momijiba
How strange it is— Where is Urago Mountain, I wonder? When all the same scarlet Seem the autumn leaves…
Kiyosuke 93
Right (Win)
大ゐ河きしのもみぢのちるをりは浪にたたするにしきとぞみる
ōigawa kishi no momiji no chiru ori wa nami ni tatasuru nishiki to zo miru
At the River Ōi, When the scarlet leaves upon the bank Come to fall, Cut out by the waves, Does their brocade appear!
Mikawa 94
When I listen to the Left I wonder what on earth it’s actually about—the end seems redolent of love. The Right doesn’t seem to have any particular faults, so it should win.