kakute nomi arite hakanaki yo no naka o ushi to ya iwan aware to ya iwan
So, simply Being here, briefly In this mundane world— Should I call cruel, or That ‘tis full of sorrow?[i]
711
[i] See: Topic unknown. よのなかにいづらわが身のありてなしあはれとやいはむあなうとやいはむ yo no naka ni / izura wa ga mi no / arite nashi / aware to ya iwamu / ana uto ya iwamu ‘Within this mundane world / Where should my sorry self / Be, or not? / Should I cry out in sorrow, or / At its cruelties?’ Anonymous (Kokinshū XVIII: 943)
A poem on how Mahāyāna[i] develops the viewpoint of the Middle Way.[ii]
世の中はかがみにうつるかげにあれやあるにもあらずなきにもあらず
yo no naka wa kagami ni utsuru kage ni are ya aru ni mo arazu naki ni mo arazu
Is this mundane world A mirror’s reflected Shape, perhaps? Not existing, and Not not existing…
653
[i] Mahāyāna (the ‘Great Vehicle’) (Jp.: daijō 大乗) is the largest major tradition of Buddhism.
[ii] The ‘Middle Way’ (Madhyamāpratipada) (Jp.: chūdō 中道) refers to a spiritual practice of Buddhism that steers clear of both extreme asceticism and sensual indulgence.
yo no naka wa tsune ni mogamo na nagisa kogu ama no obune no tsunade kanashi mo
This mundane world, I would be ever so! Rowing through the calm, A fisher’s tiny boat’s Hawsers move me most! [i]
572
[i] See: A poem from Michinoku. みちのくはいづくはあれどしほがまの浦こぐ舟のつなでかなしも michinoku wa / izuku wa aredo / shiogama no / ura kogu fune no / tsunade kanashi mo ‘O, Michinoku, / This may be true elsewhere, too, but / At Shiogama / Bay, a rowing boat’s / Hawsers move me most!’ Anonymous (Kokinshū XX: 1088)
[i] This poem is included in Kokin rokujō (4268), with the headnote ‘Sand Pear’, and also in Mandaishū (2812) with the headnote, ‘From the Poetry Match at the Residence of the Ōmi Lady of the Bedchamber’.
miya’ishite iku yo henuramu sumiyoshi no matsu fuku kaze mo kamisabinikeri
Since He manifested here How many ages might have passed? At Sumiyoshi The wind gusting through the pines, too, Is touched with divinity…
Tsunemasa 127
Right
よのなかをいとふこころはさきだちていつまでとまるうきみなるらむ
yo no naka o itou kokoro wa sakidachite itsu made tomaru ukimi naruramu
This mundane world My heart does despise and Would depart, but How long will I remain, Suffering as I am?
Nakatsuna 128
Both Left and Right are expressions of grievance, but the Left is merely concerned with ‘Since He manifested here / How many ages might have passed?’, while the Right simply wonders ‘How long will I remain’ while despising the mundane world. I cannot really say that either is superior in the emotions they express, yet due to its reference to the deity, I should say that the Left wins.